This month WikiLeaks released nearly 400,000 Pentagon documents about the war in Iraq. The U.S. government had dreaded the details getting out as much as Julian Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, had anticipated his coup. But instead of the public outrage both sides expected, the reaction was a big yawn. It turns out that traditional on-the-ground reporting over the years by war correspondents had made the ups and downs of the Iraq war well-known. The main new information was confirmation of Iranian and Hezbollah support of Shiite militias in Iraq, including their kidnapping of Americans, as the Bush administration had claimed and its critics doubted.
The big story instead is the digital-age tension between WikiLeaks, which makes it easy to disclose confidential information anonymously, and the media outlets that publicized the leaks. The leaks are raw reports from the field, from which the Pentagon crafts assessments. When journalists tried to add context and understanding to the WikiLeaks data, they found little new to report.
Instead, what is newsworthy is how Mr. Assange is both enabled and now outraged by traditional media companies—and vice versa. On the one hand, publishers including the New York Times and Britain's Guardian agreed to collaborate with WikiLeaks, running the page-one stories Mr. Assange sought about the leaks. Yet he is not grateful, and some of the traditional media companies that have collaborated with him now seem to resent the association. Mr. Assange is an Australian computer hacker who started WikiLeaks in 2006 and boasts of having no known address so that he can stay above any law.
Mr. Assange likes to call himself "the James Bond of journalism," but he's neither a spy nor a journalist. WikiLeaks simply offers an anonymous venue online for leakers to leak. It's American soldier Pfc. Bradley Manning who has been charged with the leaks. Even if Mr. Assange is charged with wrongdoing, such as under the 1917 Espionage Act, someone else could easily create the next anonymous site. The ease of digital publishing leaves few levers for prevention other than harsh punishment for leakers.
No comments:
Post a Comment